Software

CyberLink PowerDirector 14; Video Editing

In the past year or two, the amateur video landscape has advanced considerably, and CyberLink’s consumer video editing software is usually among the first with support for new formats. Before 4K content could be shot on most smartphones PowerDirector supported it. Now we’re starting to see 360-degree video and new high-efficiency codecs like H.265, and once again CyberLink is in the vanguard. And it’s still loaded with tools that help you put together a compelling video, complete with transitions, effects, and titles. It handles the standard trimming, joining, and overlaying of clips and effects with aplomb. PowerDirector’s fast, powerful video-editing tools make it the prosumer video editing software to beat.

What’s New?

For longtime, diehard PowerDirector users, here’s a rundown of new feature highlights in version 16, reviewed here. I’ll discuss and evaluate each in the appropriate sections below.

  • New 360-degree video editing tools: stabilization, motion tracking, titles, transitions, and View Designer for cool effects like the “little planet.”
  • Color tools: color matching, LUT (lookup table) filters, split toning, and HDR effects.
  • Video collages, featuring animated picture-in-picture templates.
  • Automatic audio ducking to lower background sound levels when subjects are speeking.

Pricing and Installation

PowerDirector runs on Windows 7 through Windows 10, with 64-bit versions recommended. You can try out the software with a 30-day downloadable trial version that adds brand watermarks and doesn’t support 4K. Two editions of the standalone video editor are available, the $99.99 Ultra and the $129.99 Ultimate, reviewed here. (Note that those prices are often discounted.) Another option is to bundle it with CyberLink’s ColorDirector, AudioDirector, and PhotoDirector in the Director Suite bundle, which costs $159.99.

The higher-end options add loads of third-party special effects from the likes of BorixFX, NewBlue, and proDAD. To see exactly which is in each edition, go to CyberLink’s comparison page. You can also get the complete suite for a subscription at $49.99 for three months or $99.99 per year. The pricing is competitive with that of Premiere Elements’ $99.99, Corel VideoStudio’s $99.99, and our Mac Editors’ Choice for video editing, Apple Final Cut Pro’s $299.99.

Installing the program takes up nearly a gigabyte of your hard drive, so be sure to use a machine with room to spare. I tested the Ultimate edition on my Asus Zen AiO Pro Z240IC running 64-bit Windows 10. The installer no longer tries to add extra unrelated apps alongside the video editor, which makes me happy.

Interface

The program’s user interface is about as clear and simple as a program with such a vast number of options can be, but it can still get overwhelming when you’re deep in the weeds of fine-tuning video or audio effects. It’s not quite as unintimidating as of Adobe Premiere Elements, however. You start off in a Welcome screen offering big button options of Timeline Mode, Storyboard Mode, and Slideshow Creator. Two choices below those include Auto Mode and 360 Editor—all these modes are self-explanatory.

If you don’t need or want all these choices every time you start the program, a simple Always Enter Timeline Mode checkbox is for you. On this welcome screen, you can also choose your video project’s aspect ratio—16:9, 4:3, and (new for this version) a 9:16 tall mode, since some people never seem to learn to hold their phones sideways for videos.

The PowerDirector editing interface maintains the traditional source and preview split panels on the top, with your track timeline along the whole width of the bottom of the screen. The storyboard view is more than just clip thumbnails. You can drag transitions between clips, apply effects, and add audio clips without switching to timeline view. I also like the buttons at the top for showing just video, just photos, or just audio in the source panel.

CyberLink PowerDirector 14 Interface

Four mode choices line up at the top: Capture, Edit, Produce, and Create Disc. The timeline is easy to customize and navigate, with a button for adding tracks. You’re allowed up to 100. Vegas Movie Studio limits you to 20, which is already probably more than most people need, though not enough for high-end projects. By default, you get three pairs of video and audio tracks with Cyberlink, as well as effects, title, voice, and music tracks. You can lock, disable/enable view, or rename tracks from the left track-info area, and you can even use drag and drop to move them up and down on the timeline. Zooming the timeline in and out is also a snap, either with Ctrl-Mouse wheel or a slider control.

Basic Video Editing

As with most nonlinear video editing software, you join and trim clips on the timeline. CyberLink has changed the default timeline behavior a bit with this release: Instead of a clip firmly snapping next to an existing clip on the timeline, when you drag one onto the timeline, you’re likely to overlap with the existing clip to the left. You get a tooltip with five options: Overwrite, Insert, Insert and Move All Clips, Crossfade, and Replace. If you use the Insert button that appears below the source panel when you select a clip, you can get your clip lined up without any fuss.

Edit with CyberLink

The Trim tool (opened with a scissors icon) allows precise control (down to the individual frame) with two sliders, and the multi-trim tool lets you mark several In and Out points on your clip—a useful tool for cutting out the chaff. Some professionally trained video editors I know lament, however, that you can’t do a rough trim on a clip before dragging it down into PowerDirector’s project timeline, as you can in Final Cut Pro X and Premiere Pro.

Trim in PowerDirector

You use PowerDirector’s unique and intuitive selection cursor to split video and delete sections. Fix/Enhance options also include video denoise, audio denoise, and enhancements to punch up color and sharpness. PowerDirector also makes it easy to fix lighting and color. You can independently adjust the brightness, contrast, hue, saturation, sharpness, and white balance. New for version 16 is color matching—important for movies shot at different angles with different equipment and lighting.

The new Color Match option appears when you have two clips selected, and it’s a simple matter of scrubbing to the frame in each that you want to match. It did a good job in my tests with scenery and décor, but it could benefit from face detection, as it didn’t match skin tones between clips very well. The new support for CLUTs, or color lookup tables, can give your movie a uniform look, by applying a color mood like those you see in the cinema, for example, the dark blue look of the Batman movies. PowerDirector supports a healthy number of file formats for this, including 3DL, CSP, CUBE, M3D, MGA, RV3DLUT, and VF. Unfortunately, the program doesn’t give you much support in actually locating CLUTs—you’re pretty much on your own. Pinnacle Studio, the only other consumer editor I know of with CLUT support, starts you out with a good selection of the effects, by comparison.

Assisted Movie Making

One of the best things to come to home video editors in recent years was pioneered by Apple with the Trailers feature of the Mac’s included iMovie app. Adobe recently added a similar tool, Premiere Elements’ Video Story feature. With either of these, you fill templates in with video and photo content that meets the needs of a spot in the production, such as Group shot, close-up, or Action shot. These are elaborated with transitions and background music that match your chosen theme. PowerDirector has a similar tool, Express Project, which you can enter directly from the program startup panel.

Express Project joins another similar tool, the Magic Movie Wizard, which takes you through five steps: importing source content, adjusting that content, previewing, and producing. You get four Styles to choose from, including Memory Field, Original, Fast Motion, and Slow Motion, but you can download 22 more from DirectorZone.com, Cyberlink’s Web resource site. Unlike the iMovie tool, PowerDirector requires you to add your own background music—there are no canned scores in the wizard or for Express Projects.

There are nine Express Projects available for download, including Action, Extreme, Round the World, Wedding, Adventure, Anniversary, and Love. An Express Project only requires two steps: Dragging an Opening, Middle, and Ending onto the timeline, and filling the resulting clip tracks with your media. It’s nowhere near as intuitive or clear as Apple iTunes’ Trailers feature or Adobe Premiere Elements’ Video Story feature. But it does offer guidance in crafting a digital movie, it is actually more customizable, and the results look pretty cool.

Video Collage

New for version 16 is the Video Collage Designer. This is similar to a tool that appeared in the last version of Adobe Premiere Elements. Accessed from the Plug-ins button, the Video Collage Designer shows templates with your clips on the side. You simply drag and drop the latter into the former, and you get a nifty animated picture in picture. PowerDirector already had one of the strongest picture-in-picture tools around, but this is an easier way to get a pleasing result.

Working With 360-Degree Footage

When you add a 360-degree clip to your project, PowerDirector pops up a dialog box asking whether you want your output to be 360 or 2D. If you choose the latter, the View Designer window opens, which let you choose the resulting movie’s point of view. You can move the angle around in this window’s preview in three axes (x, y, and z) with the mouse pointer.

View Designer in PowerDirector

Clicking on up, down, left, and right, arrows alters your point of view, and clicking the center of the arrow control snaps the view to straight on. You can zoom the view, and very usefully, use keyframes to automatically switch from one viewpoint to another. That last option can take advantage of the Ease In option, which makes the motion more naturally accelerate and decelerate, rather than happening mechanically.

A very cool new effect, which I first saw on Vimeo, is produced by the Little Planet dropdown in the View Designer. This takes 360-degree content and realigns it so that the ground is shaped like a ball that any people in the video are walking around. Drag on the image downward and you can create the opposite type of world, in which the inhabitants are on the inside of a sphere. A cool option is to use keyframes to rotate the world smoothly.

Little Planet in CyberLink PowerDirector

Also new for 360 videos are stabilization and, remarkably, motion tracking. CyberLink has really pushed the envelope with these first-mover features. Unfortunately, I could not get good stabilization results in footage from my Samsung Gear 360, but when I tried sample shaky footage from CyberLink’s Steven Lien, the feature worked well.

Motion tracking works about the same as it does in 2D footage, except the selection box changes shape to reflect its position in 3D space. It’s a simple three-step process: You box the object you want to track, run the tracker, and then attach text or graphics to follow it. Lo and behold: It works better than any motion tracking I’ve tested to date. The tracker displayed a circle centering on and a box around the colleagues head I was tracking, and it locked on perfectly. In the past these tools have tended to lose the tracked object, being distracted by background objects. It even kept up with the trackee when he walked behind a glass door. That’s impressive!

For projects that you intend to output in 360-degree format, you can still use the basic trimming, splitting, and joining editing tools, but there are a bunch of PowerDirector features you cannot use: Magic Movie, video cropping (think about it), and content-aware editing. You also cannot successfully mix non-360 content into a 360 project.

Adding titles and transitions is still possible, as is making color corrections, and time speedups and slowdowns. The program now offers 11 360-degree title options, including some with fly-in animations. You can also change up the fonts with over 100 choices and apply effects like stroke and drop shadow. These 360 titles stay in place as the viewer moves around, rather than just statically remaining over the image. But you can also move them around, change transparency, and scale, all using keyframes—pretty cool.

Once you’ve edited the content to taste, you output to H.264 MP4 format, or you can upload directly to Facebook, YouTube, and now Vimeo, as well. The exporter lets you choose a privacy level and resolution, including 4K as an option. The 360 editor doesn’t let you export to H.265, which would be nice considering the file size of 360-degree 4K content and H.265’s superior compression. PowerDirector can export to H.265 for standard, non-360 content, however.

Action Camera Tools

PowerDirector can of course import and edit footage from GoPro cameras, as well as from other action cameras from the likes of Sony, Kodak, and Ion. But the dedicated Action Camera Center under the Tools menu item appears when you select a clip. This offers effects like camera-profile-based corrections for fisheye distortion, vignette, camera shake, and color. It also includes effects favored by action cam users, such as freeze-frame and time-shifts like slowdowns, speedups, and replays.

Action Camera in PowerDirector

The fisheye fix has an advantage over GoPro’s own video editor in that it cuts off less of the edge of the screen, and in my test shot it distorted faces less than the GoPro software. Stabilization isn’t an option in the stock GoPro software, and CyberLink offers enhanced stabilization and the ability to fix camera rotation for a smoother look. The enhanced stabilization (which takes much longer) did a nice job of smoothing out bumpy shots, but I still occasionally saw some warping—a common artifact of stabilization technology.

The Effect tab of Action Camera Center is where you find the highly in-demand Replay, Speed, and Freeze-Frame tools. The first offers buttons for replay and reverse, and speed effects. You choose how long a piece of the clip the effect should be applied to, and from check boxes you can choose Ease In and Ease Out options. The tool lets you easily create fun effects that are prized by skateboarders, surfers, and other fun lovers.

Another tangentially action-cam related capability is the ability to import and edit clips shot at a high frame rate, such as 120fps and 240fps. I imported a sample of the latter from an iPhone 6, and when I dragged it into my timeline, I got a warning box telling me the frame rate differed from that of my project, but Settings only offered a maximum of 60fps for a project. A CyberLink contact informed me that the limit only applied to the timeline view, and assured me that 240fps content is preserved at output time. Adding a slo-mo effect to my test clip turned a hand clap into a terrifying bass thump.

PowerDirector has a Stop Motion effect in the Action Camera Center, but it’s not like Corel VideoStudio’s real stop-motion tool, which lets you create your own Rudolf the Red-Nosed Reindeer. In PowerDirector, the tool simply freezes the action for a specified amount of time on selected frames.

Motion Tracking

Motion tracking lets an object, text, or effect follow around something moving in your video. You pick the Motion Tracker choice from the same Tools menu as the Action Camera, after selecting a clip in the timeline. The tool makes tracking an object and adding a title, effect, or even another media clip a simple three-step process. You start by positioning a target box on the object you want tracked, then press the Track button, which runs through the video while following your boxed object. And then you choose what you want to follow the tracked object.

As mentioned above, the 360-degree tracker worked extremely well, but the 2D tracker still lost track of my subject’s face when he turned around, a common limitation in such tools. I fixed this pretty easily by stopping the tracking, realigning the box, and starting tracking again. It’s easier to get a track correct than in Corel VideoStudio. Adobe Premiere Elements’ motion tracking tool also lost track of a skateboarder in my test footage when he passed behind a pole.

Motion Track in PowerDirector

For attaching text to motion-tracked objects in PowerDirector, you can easily attach a mosaic, spotlight, or blur effect, and you get a good choice of many fonts, colors, and sizes. You can even rotate the text with a handle. One thing I’d like to be able to add, however, is a speech bubble, something offered by Adobe and Corel.

Content-Aware and Multicam Editing

PowerDirector can analyze your clip for people, zooming, panning, speech, motion, and shaky video. This enables you to select or reject areas of interest or boringness. Premiere Elements has a tool that lets you manually pick your favorite moments, but it’s not automated like PowerDirector’s. The Edit using Content Aware Editing right-click choice processes a clip, and then it shows a dialog with tracks for each of the detected events, such as Zoom, Pan, Faces, Speech, Shaky video, poor lighting, and more. Clicking on any of the detected clip segments lets you easily select or deselect that portion of the clip for use in your project. Note that this feature doesn’t work with 360-degree content.

With so many people shooting events simultaneously with their HD camera phones, multicam is no longer just for professionals. PowerDirector allows up to 100 multicam tracks, but what this really means is that you can sync that many tracks by audio in the main timeline. The actual multicam-switching interface still just has four video sources.

For synchronization, you get a choice of Audio Analysis (the best choice for amateurs), Manual, Timecodes, File Created Time, and Markers on Clips. When I used Audio Analysis, my two clips synced perfectly. The program lets you choose which track’s audio should be used, or you can import a separate audio track. Hitting Record played all angles synchronized, letting me switch among them. The tool creates sub-clips labeled 1 to 4 for the camera angles, with adjustable split points.

When you’re done cutting, the clip sequence appears on the regular timeline. Subclips are in separate tracks, but you can’t adjust the cut points there without losing footage and messing up the synchronization. The multicam designer itself lets you adjust these. Thankfully, you can also reopen a multicam sequence in the designer after you’ve sent it to the timeline. In all, it’s a well-done and powerful tool.

Near-Pro Video Editing

If you’re into keyframe editing (which allows precise control over when effects begin and end based on exact frames you choose) PowerDirector is there for you. It offers picture-in-picture (PiP), overlays, motion, cropping, and time codes. All effects and adjustments can be pegged to keyframes. You get over 100 transitions and special effects to choose from, including ten from NewBlue. And the app lets you install third-party effect plug-ins from Pixelan and ProDAD.

Transitions are easy to add, and the program can decide what material before and after to use when you drop this kind of effect to a join line between clips. A search box lets you find a specific type, like Page Curl. And you can even create custom transitions using your images with the Alpha set of transitions, which rely on masking and transparency. It’s fun making a transition out of a friend’s head, as shown below.

CyberLink PowerDirector Custom Transition

PowerDirector’s chroma-key tool lets you shoot someone with a single-color background, usually green, and create the effect of him or her being in an exotic scene by choosing a different background. Controls for tolerance of saturation, luminance, and edge sharpness let you create more-precise masks, and even in the default mode, I noticed none of the green halo I sometimes see around test subjects in other programs.

A new Mask Designer lets you add transparency to mask objects (including your own images) and text. It was pretty fun to use my mugshot as a mask over a flowing river in the test video below. As with just about every effect, you can use keyframes to gradually ease in and out of these mask effects.

The program offers preset PiP grids—from 2 by 2 to 10 by 10—and your clip tracks snap to fill the resulting spaces. The PiP Designer window makes creating PiP movies simpler than in any competing app. And none of the competition can preview these types of movies without stop-and-start jerky playback.

4K and 3D

PowerDirector supports 4K video content. The software supports XAVC-S standard of 4K and HD videos used in Sony cameras and camcorders. This joins support for Canon 1DC, JVC HMQ-10, and GoPro Hero3 4K content.

In editing Go Pro 4K footage, performance is better than I expected, not even slowing down with complex transitions. Being first with 4K capability is a real feather in CyberLink’s cap, but much of the competition, such as Corel VideoStudio, now supports 4K.

FACE MASK RIVER from Michael M on Vimeo.

Unlike Premiere Elements, PowerDirector can import, edit, display, and produce 3D video. It can even attempt to convert 2D content to 3D. It supports various 3D systems, including anaglyph (red/cyan glasses), 3D-ready HDTVs, and popular video and photo 3D formats. I downloaded several 3D samples, including high-definition content, and PowerDirector had no problem displaying it. Once you’ve got your 3D content in the program, you can add 3D transitions, particles, and titles.

Audio

Audio tracks in the timeline by default show waveform lines, and you can turn up and down volume by grabbing and dragging them. The Audio Room, a simple track-volume mixer, features Normalize buttons for each track to even out clip sound levels. It’s also easy to create voiceovers with the Voice-Over Recording Room, accessible from a tab sporting a microphone icon. CyberLink’s WaveEditor is a separate included app that lets you correct distortion, equalize, generate reverb, and apply a few special effects. It also includes VST plug-in support for third-party effects.

The standard video editor also includes beat detection, which puts markers on the timeline at music beats so you can synchronize clip action. But for really advanced mixing, recording, syncing, cleaning, and restoration, there’s AudioDirector (included with the Ultimate Suite edition). With this separate app you can easily apply effects and fixes that are preserved when you later open them in PowerDirector. New for version 16 is automatic ducking, which doesn’t add quacks to your soundtrack. Instead, it automatically lowers background audio during dialog on another track. It didn’t do much for a loud concert video on top of an interview but worked better with a standard background track.

Performance

CyberLink’s investment in 64-bit optimizations and graphics hardware acceleration has paid off. Other speed-boosters include OpenCL (Open Computing Language) support and intelligent SVRT, which determines how your clips should be rendered for the best-quality output and fastest editing. In my latest round of performance testing, the program remains the fastest among its peers.

I tested rendering time by creating a movie consisting of four clips of mixed types (some 1080p, some SD, some 4K) with a standard set of transitions and rendered it to 1080p30 MPEG-4 at 15Mbps, H.264 High Profile. Audio was MPEG AAC Audio: 192 Kbps. I tested on the Asus Zen AiO Pro Z240IC running 64-bit Windows 10 Home and sporting a 4K display, 16GB RAM, a quad-core Intel Core i7-6700T CPU, and an Nvidia GeForce GTX 960M discrete graphics card.

The test movie (whose duration was just under 5 minutes) took 1:59 (minutes:seconds) for PowerDirector to render; Corel VideoStudio took 4:20 and Adobe Premiere Elements took 5:18. Only Pinnacle Studio bested it, with a time of 1:35. But PowerDirector is certainly among the leaders. Its render speed with OpenCL acceleration enabled is nothing short of astonishing. During rendering, PowerDirector also shows you the time elapsed, time remaining, and what frame in the movie you’re at during the process.

Real Power for Your Video Edits

PowerDirector continues to lead the way among consumer video editing software. And there’s even more in this powerful, full-featured video editing software package than I have room to discuss even in such a long review as this—slideshows, disc menus, and animated object design tools to name just a few. Its wealth of powerful tools would be enough to give it a strong recommendation, but the speed with which PowerDirector handles editing and rendering digital movies really gives it the upper hand in the face of many competing products. CyberLink PowerDirector 16 Ultimate remains PCMag’s Editors’ Choice for enthusiast-level video-editing software, along with Corel VideoStudio and, for Mac users, Apple Final Cut Pro X.


Source link

Show More

Related Articles

Close

Adblock Detected

Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker